Talk:Lost Whispers (song): Difference between revisions

From The Evanescence Reference
No edit summary
(→‎Sources: new section)
Line 15: Line 15:
-Amy}}
-Amy}}
--[[User:Sweet Sacrifice|Sweet Sacrifice]] ([[User talk:Sweet Sacrifice|talk]]) 01:15, 14 April 2023 (PDT)
--[[User:Sweet Sacrifice|Sweet Sacrifice]] ([[User talk:Sweet Sacrifice|talk]]) 01:15, 14 April 2023 (PDT)
== Sources ==
Given that Amy posted that in November 2009 after the only two Ev shows of that year (not counting the L&L performance), she was referring to the intro of said shows, i.e. then-untitled Lost Whispers. As her post on the Maquinaria announcement thread is no longer available because 1. The forum was taken down in 2012 and 2. This post was not saved by webarchive, we rely on sources from fansites that reposted her quote "without a context". Here I'm giving the context. I remember to this day that she posted that because I was a user on EvThreads at the time.
EvWebsite is a reliable source because they were recognised by Amy. They wouldn't make this things up. They just copied and pasted her quote.
Here's the link to her specific post, but you can't access it due to the above-mentioned reasons: http://www.evthreads.com/showpost.php?p=1222777&postcount=928
That said, may I undo Undermosa's deletions?

Revision as of 04:08, 14 April 2023

Lost Whisper edit war

http://web.archive.org/web/20091125155302/http://www.amy-l.net/

I found this other source for now. Unfortunately, the original source is no more available. Amy in a post on evthreads talked about the song and shared the lyrics (November 2009). Before deleting such large parts of text, I recommend starting a discussion to avoid edit wars. Furthermore, if a source is not considered reliable, it would be better to use the "fact" template [citation needed]

Vin1.jpg The words I was singing in the intro were:

Lost whispers
awaken within me
and fly...

Kind of like a prayer to reconnect to the old music, my old self. Calling it all back to me.
I’m glad we were able to use at least just a minute of new music. Terry and I wrote that a few months ago and its been in the “half done” bin for awhile. I think it turned into a beautiful intro.

-Amy

Vin2.jpg

--Sweet Sacrifice (talk) 01:15, 14 April 2023 (PDT)

Sources

Given that Amy posted that in November 2009 after the only two Ev shows of that year (not counting the L&L performance), she was referring to the intro of said shows, i.e. then-untitled Lost Whispers. As her post on the Maquinaria announcement thread is no longer available because 1. The forum was taken down in 2012 and 2. This post was not saved by webarchive, we rely on sources from fansites that reposted her quote "without a context". Here I'm giving the context. I remember to this day that she posted that because I was a user on EvThreads at the time.

EvWebsite is a reliable source because they were recognised by Amy. They wouldn't make this things up. They just copied and pasted her quote.

Here's the link to her specific post, but you can't access it due to the above-mentioned reasons: http://www.evthreads.com/showpost.php?p=1222777&postcount=928

That said, may I undo Undermosa's deletions?